The European Union’s plan to issue a pioneering reparations loan for Ukraine has suffered a significant blow after Euroclear, the central securities depository holding most of the bloc’s immobilised Russian assets, issued its strongest warning yet about the proposal’s risks.
The intervention has intensified political tensions in Brussels, where German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Belgian Prime Minister Bart De Wever held crisis talks on Friday alongside European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen.
Euroclear described the plan as “very fragile”, unpredictable, and potentially damaging for the eurozone’s credibility. Under the proposal, the European Commission would use the immobilised assets of the Russian Central Bank—frozen since Moscow’s invasion—to create a zero-interest credit line for Ukraine.
Kyiv would repay the loan only if Russia agreed to compensate for war damages, a scenario analysts widely view as improbable.
The EU hopes to cover €90 billion of Ukraine’s €135 billion financing needs for 2026–27 through this mechanism. But because Euroclear is headquartered in Brussels, Belgium wields a decisive vote on the plan—one it has been reluctant to offer.
Euroclear warned that the legal framework for transforming Russia’s sovereign assets into collateral for a loan lacks clarity and could expose the organisation, Belgium, and the EU to financial, legal, and reputational dangers.
“This initiative could have far-reaching legal, financial, and reputational risks for Euroclear, Belgium, the European Union and its financial markets,” a spokesperson said.
One of the most sensitive concerns involves liquidity. If EU sanctions on Russia were lifted unexpectedly and member states failed to raise €185 billion in guarantees, Euroclear says it might be unable to meet potential claims from the Russian Central Bank.
Belgian authorities fear that losing such a case in court could devastate the national treasury—possibly even bankrupt the country.
Retaliation is another critical worry. Euroclear holds around €17 billion in assets inside Russia, which the Kremlin could seize in response. While the European Commission says Euroclear could then access assets held by the Russian National Settlement Depository in Europe, the legal path to such recovery remains murky.
Beyond direct risks, Euroclear has warned of broader financial consequences. International investors, it says, may interpret the mechanism as a de facto confiscation of sovereign assets—undermining trust in Europe’s financial markets and raising borrowing costs for EU governments.
Von der Leyen has acknowledged these concerns in private letters to leaders but maintains the proposal is legally sound.
Belgium, Germany, and the Commission are now racing to find a compromise before EU leaders meet on 18 December for a crucial summit. Ukraine, facing a sharp funding gap, will require new international support as early as April.
Complicating matters further, the United States has reportedly pressured several EU capitals to block the loan, arguing it could prolong the war by removing diplomatic leverage. Euroclear CEO Valerie Urbain echoed similar concerns, suggesting the funds would be more useful in peace negotiations than in supporting an uncertain legal structure.
If the reparations loan fails, the EU may instead raise €90 billion in joint debt—an option Belgium prefers but others resist. The coming weeks may determine not only Ukraine’s financial stability but also the EU’s unity on one of its most consequential decisions in years.