As global frustration mounts over the slow progress in curbing greenhouse gas emissions, geoengineering strategies to reflect sunlight away from Earth are drawing increasing attention.
However, leading scientists have warned of dramatic and unpredictable consequences from such interventions, urging caution and stronger global governance.
Solar Radiation Modification (SRM), a subset of geoengineering, includes speculative methods such as injecting reflective aerosols into the stratosphere or brightening marine clouds with salt spray.
While these technologies remain largely theoretical, the European Commission’s Scientific Advice Mechanism issued a stark warning today about the potential dangers of deploying such techniques.
“Deploying these technologies could trigger climate effects in different parts of the world that are difficult to predict and manage,” said Nebojsa Nakicenovic, a member of the EU’s Group of Chief Scientific Advisors.
The concerns were echoed by Benjamin Sovacool, co-chair of the working group that authored the reports. He outlined the risks of SRM, including disruptions to ecosystems, altered rainfall patterns, and diminished food production.
“Moreover, these approaches fail to address direct greenhouse gas impacts, such as ocean acidification and shifts in vegetation,” Sovacool added.
A Short-Sighted Fix?
Barbara Prainsack, chair of the European Group on Ethics, raised alarms about the ethical implications of SRM technologies.
“While some proposals might address symptoms of climate change, they do not tackle its root causes,” she said. Prainsack cautioned that presenting SRM as a viable solution could undermine ongoing efforts to reduce emissions and adapt to climate change.
SRM techniques would require long-term global implementation and could result in unintended consequences, experts warned.
Without an established framework for governance, compensation mechanisms, and representation for affected populations, such technologies could exacerbate global inequalities.
“No such framework exists, and it is unclear how one could be developed,” the advisory boards concluded in their report.
A Call for a Moratorium
In response to these concerns, the advisory boards recommended that the European Union prioritize emission reduction and climate adaptation measures over speculative geoengineering techniques.
They proposed a Europe-wide moratorium on SRM technologies and urged the EU to advocate for a global non-use agreement while exploring governance frameworks for potential future decisions.
“Research in this field must be rigorous, ethical, and transparent about uncertainties,” the report emphasized. It also called for comprehensive reviews every five to ten years to reassess scientific and ethical considerations.
Warnings from the Past and Present
Cynthia Scharf, a senior fellow at the Centre for Future Generations, welcomed the emphasis on caution.
“The floods in Valencia and the lack of progress in Baku highlight the urgent dangers of an unraveling climate,” Scharf stated, stressing the importance of understanding potential unintended consequences.
As climate emergencies escalate, scientists and policymakers are striving to balance innovation with caution. While geoengineering may offer hope to some, experts agree that reducing greenhouse gas emissions remains the most reliable and equitable path forward.