An audit from the European Court of Auditors (ECA) has revealed that €12 billion of EU funds intended to support organic farming since 2014 have failed to boost production significantly, raising concerns about the bloc’s ability to meet its ambitious 2030 organic farming goals.
The ECA report, published on September 23, criticized member states for inconsistent application of EU funds and a lack of conditionality requiring farmers to produce organic products in return for financial support.
The audit also found that the EU has not established clear mechanisms to measure the environmental benefits of organic farming, which has contributed to the sector’s stagnant growth.
According to the report, organic farming currently accounts for just 4% of the total EU food market, a figure that auditors called alarmingly low given the EU’s goal to increase the share of agricultural land farmed organically to 25% by 2030.
The target, part of the EU’s broader Farm to Fork Strategy aimed at fostering sustainable agricultural practices, remains non-binding. However, the ECA warned that substantial gaps in definitions, funding conditionality, and implementation across member states mean the target is unlikely to be achieved.
Significant Discrepancies Across Member States
One of the core issues flagged by the auditors was the uneven uptake of organic farming across EU countries. Austria stands out, with more than 25% of its agricultural land dedicated to organic farming, while in Bulgaria, Ireland, Malta, the Netherlands, and Poland, this figure is below 5%. The lack of uniformity, driven by national policies that interpret EU regulations differently, has resulted in a fragmented landscape for organic farming within the bloc.
“To get back on track, the uptake of organic farming practices in Europe would need to double,” the ECA stressed, noting that the EU has committed an additional €15 billion under the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) to support organic farming until 2027.
Without a significant overhaul in how these funds are allocated and used, the auditors cautioned that this additional funding might be similarly ineffective.
Weak Monitoring and No Conditionality
The auditors identified a critical flaw in the lack of conditionality attached to the funding. Farmers receiving EU support were not consistently required to produce organic products, and the environmental benefits that should accompany organic farming were not rigorously measured. This, the audit said, had led to a situation where vast sums were spent with little accountability or tangible results.
The ECA called for the European Commission to introduce “quantifiable targets,” “milestones and timelines,” and “indicators to monitor progress” if the EU’s 2030 organic farming goals are to be met. They also highlighted the need for clearer definitions of organic farming practices across member states to ensure that funding is being used effectively.
Missing the 2030 Target
With organic farming currently occupying a small fraction of the EU’s agricultural landscape, the ECA’s findings suggest that the 2030 target is in serious jeopardy. The auditors underscored the urgency of addressing these systemic issues, as failure to do so could undermine the EU’s broader environmental objectives, which are closely tied to reducing carbon emissions and promoting biodiversity.
The report’s conclusions are likely to prompt discussions within EU institutions and among member states about how best to reform organic farming policies. In the face of rising consumer demand for sustainable food production, the EU’s failure to make significant headway in this sector may draw further scrutiny in the coming months.